An East Asian Reply to Africa’s Economic Voldemort

The talk of economic empowerment, economic liberation or the rise and emancipation of a dilapidated Africa is one that is more often than not, met with drooping shoulders and heavy sighs. The prospect itself is gratifying but growing up with an inexplicable vision of 23 million people dying a day from starvation and 47% of the continent’s population living under poverty, we simply exclaim at how wondrous that all would be. Cases of corruption that is so severe that it stashes away almost 0.77% of the continent’s GDP annually leave us disheveled and disillusioned. Economists, with their glorious terms and upward sloping graphical predictions seem to speak of intangible hope that can not be realised… Or can it?

One song that is mouthed continuously though is the comparison of Africa to East Asia. Even lay men know that once upon a time, East Asia and Africa were almost at the same economic footing. At some point in time, both were dilapidated, reeking of poverty, disease and death. However, the countries of East Asia speak of a transformation now. With approximately staggering rates of almost 6% GDP growth annually for the past thirty years in the region, their peoples are enjoying the fruits of their labour. African streets still reek of poverty disease and death and their peoples, walk them, with hunched backs, bearing the weight of accumulated and enslaving foreign debt. In many ways, Asia and Africa gained independence, but Africa, long mentally colonised, still suffers the plight and indignation of economic slavery.

This would hence explain how we have gradually accumulated solutions to these innumerable problems that we face. Before our faces, the ideas of capitalistic ideas, democracy, a free market among others have been flaunted. Most of these though remain theoretical unvisualised ideals in the African mind. Despite our lack of knowledge of them, we hold onto them dearly. They translate to the only refuge we know to liberate ourselves. The price is ransom for our continent.

Hence, we swallow whole some of these concepts tossed around by educated men and women in three piece suits, sited in four walled air conditioned rooms, in a metropolis somewhere. If indeed, democracy and capitalism are the foundational basis to economic growth, what would explain the almost mysterious way in which East Asia rose? Despite the popular cry that the cities are filled with “determined-to-the-point-of-suicide” fellows, examining the policy that shaped one of the world’s regional powers would not only debunk some propagated myths, but also, contextualise a rise to greatness that is most often than not, shrouded in an elusive mystery.

Most of these countries began their monumental rise at the time after the second world war, after the start of the cold war. “The Iron curtain has descended Winston Churchill time…” The world was divided on the lines of capitalistic countries and communist or socialist countries and the major players fought hard to gain as much traffic on their side as possible. At that time, it meant pouring as much money in devastated countries as possible. This explains the Marshall plan of the US, the rebuilding of Europe and the resurrection of an ailing East Asia. Copious amounts were poured into East Asia. Impressive figures of almost 1.48 billion dollars (an impressive sum then and now,) were poured into Taiwan in successive instalments between the periods of 1951 to 1968 as noted from Taiwan’s Ministry of Finance. South Korea and Taiwan received loans on very generous terms with very little of their capital coming from FDI ( foreign direct investment) with FDI being 1% in total percentage to the capital flow of S. Korea and 8% of Taiwan’s, between the periods of 1951 and 1967. All this happened under the watchful eyes of authoritarian regimes and an economy infested by monopolies such as chaebols in S.Korea and the guanxiqiyes in Taiwan.

Contrary to the view held by the World Bank regarding the rise of these countries, free trade was a concept that remained intolerable. There is proof of heavy subsidisation of industries while protecting them with heavy tariffs and other barriers. They also carefully controlled investment. Funny enough, western countries opened up their markets to these countries’ goods while at the same time, not making it mandatory to have these countries open up their markets to their goods. There also seems to have been deliberate undervaluation of East Asian countries’ currency an example being under the Bretton-Woods regime where, 360 yen went for a dollar at that time. The reason was that this in turn creates an export driven need and lessens the import drive, creating a vacuum, that leads to increased industrialisation, manufacturing the import needed. Indeed, this shaped Japan’s industry. The lack of a proper functioning system of democracy was also deliberate, to ensure that an authoritarian hand would structure the functioning of the workers in such a way that a disciplined force would create the machinations for an economic leap. Recently, these countries liberalised trade and investment but this was a case of development first, then, liberalisation rather than the propagated model of development through liberalisation promoted by neoliberal economists.

As a result, one seeing the deliberate moves by the West, especially the US in ensuring a stronghold for capitalism in the East would question the praises of the World Bank, of free trade and investment to African ears attending the G8 in Camp David. It would be wise to learn from the Asians, though not to copy them blindly. African policy makers need to restructure how they view the rise of an economy, and rethink the concepts of free trade and a strong currency taught brazenly in schools. Furthermore, policies that are entrenched in culture would succeed more than they would fail. Exploring policy that encourages domestic saving and the rise of pension schemes as they have in Nigeria would be beneficial. Infrastructure in Nigeria is set to be financed by proceeds coming from pension schemes in the next decade or so. Aggressive policies that remove the thorn of corruption ailing so many of us would also serve a mighty purpose if entrenched as they were in countries like Seychelles. A powerful regional force would sufficiently serve as a market for its own goods, while toughening tariffs and investment opportunities would not only encourage consumption of our own produce but also innovation and industrialisation. The world is not as it seems and Africa needs to open its eyes and its mind in the making of sound policy as regards to its economy if it is to manuever its rise to the top, where it belongs.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “An East Asian Reply to Africa’s Economic Voldemort

  1. Well articulated Kas , i must concur with you, as i read through this post i remembered a copy of the economist with the heading “Africa is rising” It became such a buzzword that during that period and still is up to now, Subject Matter experts throw around the figures and the calculations to show that the next big economic boom is going to explode on the African continent. BUT Africa is rising for WHOM? is the the question no one seems to want to answer, surely not for Africans. I agree with you 100%, African nations need to rethink their policy making methods, policies as sensitive as economic ones should be made independent of help from the World Bank and the IMFs of this world because they are the clear representation of neoliberalism and neocolonialism.
    this is a quote from an article on illicit cash outflows “Research by Global Financial Integrity, for example, recently estimated that illicit financial outflows cost African (both North and Sub-Saharan African) economies US$55.6 billion per year from 2002-2011 (the most recent decade for which comprehensive data was available), fueling crime, corruption, and tax evasion.” It is clear our currrent policies and policy making processes are insufficient, there is a need for more dramatic and radical change on the continent.
    But currently with our systems so broken and the disease of corruption so deep in our bones, i cannot help but be pessimistic 😦 that we will get to the top where we belong , not for a long time

    Great read, i just wish many more young people like you Kas thought this hard and deep about the issues that matter most for our beloved motherland 🙂 you give me hope my sister

    Like

    1. Oh Christine. I absolutely agree with you. But funny thing is.. Some African countries are quietly making very aggressive reforms in economic policy. I would love to review some of these policies.. and their long term effects and hopefully make guys understand how crucial well thought out independent policy making is.

      I wish young people would think as well. It actually pains me when my friends don’t know and don’t care about such stuff… I feel like we are betraying our generational mission.. :-(.. Then again, you give me hope. 🙂

      Like

  2. Would love to know which countries those are, how they have gone around implementing those reforms, what impact it has had on their international relations and their image within the media :-), when you have the time you could expand more on this blog post, it would be helpful for me and other people, so yes keep exploring, keep writing and keep sharing my dear :-), i look forward to learning alot about you

    Like

  3. “I wish young people would think as well. It actually pains me when my friends don’t know and don’t care about such stuff… I feel like we are betraying our generational mission”

    That quote right there describes how I feel when I sit down with young Africans like myself and they seem to be oblivious to the issues we face on the continent. All they concern themselves with is how to further propagate corruption and reap where they have not sown.

    Anyways, I’m very encouraged by this post and I agree entirely with your analysis Kas. You raised the question, “If indeed, democracy and capitalism are the foundational basis to economic growth, what would explain the almost mysterious way in which East Asia rose?” I would like to borrow this question from you and dive into a deeper analysis on the topic. Would love to chat with you sometime. my email address is simon.emaikwu@gmail.com.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s